Film fraternity reacts on 'Vishwaroopam' ban

Mumbai, Jan 30 (IANS) Actors, movie makers and other members of the film fraternity Wednesday reacted strongly to the ban imposed by the Tamil Nadu government on Kamal Hassan's controversial film "Vishwaroopam". This is what they had to say:

Shabana Azmi: The Supreme Court ruled in the case of Prakash Jha's film "Aarakshan" that once a movie was cleared by the Censor Board Of Film Certification no state can impose a ban on a film. It is the government's business to give value to its own certification and ensure the film is shown. Those who protest have the right to do so. But if they do so violently then the law of the land must apply to them.

If people are offended by "Vishwaroopam" let them not watch the film. How can they take away the right of others who want to watch it? The Tamil Nadu government is being unfair to "Vishwaroopam" and to the minorities it claims to protect.

For starters, have they even watched the film? India's audience is not a monolith. Some may be moved, some may be offended, or claim to be offended for political gains. So be it. Nobody is forcing the film down anyone's throat. The space for freedom of expression is shrinking and we must act now to stem the tide.

Shyam Benegal: What is happening to Kamal's film is very peculiar. It reeks of some kind of a vendetta. It doesn't make any sense. The fact is the hero of the film plays a patriotic Muslim doing good things for the country.

They've simply gone against their own rules. Once the censorboard clears the film and if any section of the audience has any doubts or fears, the matter must be referred back to the censor board. You (the state) cannot do things entirely on your own. If you are doing things on your own then why have the censor board in the first place?

A censor certificate is valid in the entire country, and should not be disregarded in one state. A censor certificate has semi-judicial status.

R. Balki: What if all the people, Muslims or Hindus, who have no issues with the film want a ban on the government? Will the courts hear that? We are scared of law and order issues because of the government.

Kalpana Lajmi: Once the certificate of release is issued by the censor board and after the film is released, no private or judicial institution or government, be it the state or centre, should exercise its diktat and influence to ban the film, whatsoever be its content. A ban is also tantamount to curbing the freedom of expression.

Hansal Mehta: All a big farce. After the hullabaloo dies down Kamal Haasan would be left counting his losses. Sad that an icon is treated so shabbily in our country.

Ketan Mehta: This is complete nonsense. The government is succumbing to cultural terrorism in spite of the censor board clearing the film. Isn't freedom of expression a fundemantal right? Democracy is meaningless without it. Please stop this recurring blackmail of creativity and the arts.

Rensil d'Silva: I think it's time we got some rules firmly in place. If the censor board passes a film for screening, the government shouldn't bow down to vested interests. Mobs cannot decide what films we should make.

Priyadarshan: Nobody has the right to ban the freedom of expression.

Subhash Kapoor: I think this is an attack on freedom of expression of a filmmaker. It is not only undemocratic but also sets a dangerous precedent. The state should not succumb to such pressure tactics by politically motivated groups.

Umesh Shukla: Freedom of expression is a must for every filmmaker.

Anusha Rizvi: The ban is ridiculous and needs to be condemned in the strongest possible terms. Our cultural space is increasingly being taken over by the right-wing discourse. All of us need to be on guard against this invasion of freedom and we must protest against it. I stand by Kamal Haasan and am deeply alarmed at the decision taken by the Tamil Nadu government.

Siddharth: "Vishwaroopam" must be edited beyond recognition if it wants to be screened in Tamil Nadu. This is the death knell for democracy, secularism and cinema. The ban on Vishwaroopam is regressive.

It's a back-to-the-dark ages blow by the Tamil Nadu government. How do we make a change? My deepest condolences to Kamal Haasan.

Khushboo: If this can happen to a man who has put in 50 years and every penny he has earned into films, and someone who eats, drinks, breathes and lives for the love of cinema, I wonder what lies in store for others.

Mani Shankar: It's a gross travesty of creative freedom. I can't understand how any state government can usurp power from the CBFC which has cleared "Vishwaroopam". Is one censor board not enough? Do filmmakers have to please every government and non-government body to release a film?

Abbas Tyrewala: Our land cannot be governed by the perpetual fear of someone objecting to everything because everyone will object to something.

Ananth Mahadevan: I haven't seen "Vishwaroopam" as yet. But from what I've gathered after its Cochin and New York shows, the film is as much an entertainer as any mass appeal film.

Most Viewed

  • Who Is Twinkle Khanna’s Daughter Nitara Buying Flowers For?
    Who Is Twinkle Khanna’s Daughter Nitara Buying Flowers For?

    Proud parents Akshay Kumar and Twinkle Khanna never got their daughter Nitara Khanna Bhatia publicly. In 2012, during the death Anniversary of Rajesh Khanna that was the first time 10 month old Nitara was clicked by the shutterbugs. Nitara looked cute dressed in pink with cute little hair clip accessorized her hair. Later in 2014, during Makar Sankrati, Akshay Kumar celebrated it with his daughter Nitara. …

  • Age gracefully, don't cover the lines: Kareena Kapoor
    Age gracefully, don't cover the lines: Kareena Kapoor

    New Delhi, Feb 27 (IANS) Bollywood's fit and fabulous Kareena Kapoor is on her way to turn 35, and she's clear about not attempting to be 22! She feels the key to ageing gracefully lies in letting the "lines" be, especially when it comes to men. I hate it when I look at somebody and know that they have tried to cover the lines," Kareena told IANS in an interview on a recent visit to the capital. Looking svelte in a golden shimmering gown, exuding a rare glow and charm, Kareena shared her …

  • Dum Laga Ke Haisha: Bhumi Pednekar’s Journey From An Assistant To A Heroine
    Dum Laga Ke Haisha: Bhumi Pednekar’s Journey From An Assistant To A Heroine

    After Parineeti, it’s Bhumi Pednekar, who is the new heroine.Weighing 85 kgs, she is obviously here to change the way we look at heroines.Rani Mukherji was at YRF recently where she saw portions of the film starring Bhumi.Rani was amazed to see the confidence and screen presence Bhumi had and asked the team to inform her whenever she is around as she personally wanted to meet Bhumi. In fact, Bhumi was also looking into the casting for Maardani and that’s when she had interacted with Rani …

  • Shah Rukh Khan Comments On Salman Khan’s Bigg Boss And Aamir Khan’s Satyamev Jayate
    Shah Rukh Khan Comments On Salman Khan’s Bigg Boss And Aamir Khan’s Satyamev Jayate

    At a press conference for his new TV game show ‘India Poochega – Sabse Shaana Kaun‘, Shah Rukh Khan was asked why he does question-answer sort of shows, to which SRK said that he likes doing that sort of TV shows. The actor went further on and gave his views on the other different shows like Salman Khan‘s Bigg Boss and Aamir Khan‘s Satyamev Jayate, SRK said, “I think they are all wonderful. “I have never been offered Bigg Boss, I’ve not been offered those shows. …

  • Did You Know Sushant Singh Rajput Used To Spy On Girlfriend Ankita Lokhande!
    Did You Know Sushant Singh Rajput Used To Spy On Girlfriend Ankita Lokhande!

    Bollywood’s young’un Sushant Singh Rajput is running on his toes with the promotion of his upcoming film Detective Byomkesh Bakshy! During a promotional event when asked if he has done anything detective like in real life, Sushant Singh admitted something rather unsual. The 29-year-old actor revealed that he has in fact spied on people who are really close to him that includes fiancé Ankita Lokhande. Sushant Singh admitted that he is very possessive by nature, and that he always keeps an eye …

  • Kapil Sharma Clarifies On The Rumour Made On Him And Shah Rukh Khan
    Kapil Sharma Clarifies On The Rumour Made On Him And Shah Rukh Khan

    Since yesterday, much loved comedian Kapil Sharma has been in target on the rumours that he has refused to appear on Shah Rukh Khan’s TV show, India Poochega Sabse Shaana Kaun? The ongoing rumours said that Kapil Sharma has apparently turned down the invitation to appear as a guest on SRK’s upcoming TV show. I can’t say no to u ever @iamsrk bhai.. Love u always :) Everyone knows that Bollywood star Shah Rukh Khan and Kapil Sharma share a good friendship since long time. SRK has appeared …

  • Gautam Gulati’s New Found Love
    Gautam Gulati’s New Found Love

    Bigg Boss 8 contestant Gautam Gulati received a lot of love from his female fan following. After winning the Bigg Boss 8 trophy as a winner, he created more buzz on social media as well as amongst female fan following. Gautam Gulati calls his fan following as Ggians and he usually stays updated and in touch with them on social media websites. Among all the messages, Gautam Gulati received a heart warming letter from one of his fan named Yashvi Jangid. …

  • Nawazuddin Siddqui Thinks Being Compared To Irrfan Khan Is Insulting!
    Nawazuddin Siddqui Thinks Being Compared To Irrfan Khan Is Insulting!

    We had recently reported that Irrfan Khan actually walked out of an interview when questioned about colleague Nawazuddin Siddiqui. The two have been constantly compared ever since Nawazuddin started delivering stellar performances and it is important to note that Irrfan is much more senior that Siddiqui. We now hear that Nawazuddin, who garnered a lot of acclaim for his role in Badlapur is not too happy about the comparisons either. …

Loading...