An Open Letter To Sajid Khan

By Martin D'Souza, Glamsham Editorial

You call yourself a blockbuster director. That's what all the posters of your recent film, HIMMATWALA, scream. But I think now it is safe to say that this film is a blockbuster disaster!

What I would like to point out is how film-directors go about town, tom-tomming about their film as though it is the next GONE WITH THE WIND or MACKENNA'S GOLD, or closer home SHOLAY!

What I fail to understand is why go to extreme lengths for such obscene promotions and tall claims? Agreed, a lot of money has been pumped in, into making a blockbuster. But that does not mean adding a few more crores to the expenditure (read marketing) is going to change the fate of the film. What you have done, you have done; now let the audience decide. If they like it, they will lap it, if they don't; they are going to be livid! I mean marketing can only do so much, if you know what I mean! And no amount of in-your-face-marketing is going to change the fate of a bad film.

You can't insult audience sensibilities with crass which masquerades as genius. The lid is going to be blown off some day. You can fool some people some time, but you cannot fool all the people all the time!

It's good to have self-belief and confidence in one's abilities, but there has to be a fine line between believing and shoving your beliefs onto millions of others. What you have done with HIMMATWALA takes immense strength. For that alone, I salute you. And no, I am not being sarcastic here. It's good to have tried and failed than not to have tried at all.

But what I would like to ask is, "why not try your hand at creativity?" That is what your field is all about. Why remake or rewrite (your term) something that has already been done and dusted. Be true to your craft. If you are in the creative field meant to entertain, at least be genuine. There is not dearth of talent (read writers) around. Give these guys a chance and a fair price for their talent. Don't short-change theme. Believe me, you, and the entire industry will have fresh content and newer ideas instead of sitting with old DVDs and scratching your heads.

What also surprised me (and here I have to laud Ajay Devgn for his Himmat) is that you said that this would be his re-launch. Come again? Your poster says, "Starring superstar Ajay Devgn." Has he fallen on bad times that he needs to be re-launched? Is he a Rahul Roy or Avinash Wadhwan?

And yet you yourself say, "Superstar"!

The explosive West Indian cricketer Vivian Richards never said he would score a century in this or that match; Lionel Messi, the Argentinian soccer star, does not say I will hammer three goals tonight; nor does Sachin Tendulkar say I will tear this attack to pieces. As a performer, their job is to perform. Bouquets and brickbats are to follow later.

Scripture in Proverbs 27:2 is clear when it states: "Let someone else praise you, and not your own mouth; an outsider, and not your own lips."

I am not against marketing, but whatever you can save from 'obscene marketing' [that amount] can go to bettering the lives of villagers in the interiors of Maharashtra and this country. This is not only for you, but for other production houses as well.

I would like to end by saying that it will be a real Mard who will still be watching Himmatwala. Because, jo Mard hota hai, unhe dard nahi hota!


Martin D'Souza

(This weekly column tries to be as honest as honest can be... )

More on bollywood at


Did you know that you can get stories like this on the Yahoo mail app?
Download it here.

Latest News

  • 'Walking Dead' actor Gilliam arrested for drunken driving in Georgia

    (Reuters) - Actor Seth Gilliam, who plays a priest on the hit TV zombie series "The Walking Dead," is facing charges in Georgia of drunken driving, speeding and drug possession after he was caught driving 107 miles per hour (172 kph) on a highway not far from where the show is filmed. The actor, who plays Father Gabriel Stokes on the popular AMC show, was pulled over early on Sunday morning in Peachtree City, about 25 miles (40 km) southwest of Atlanta, where police said they smelled alcohol …

  • Germany's Gerhaher is top classical singer for Britain's RPS

    German baritone Christian Gerhaher was named best classical singer of 2014 and Latvian Andris Nelsons the year's best conductor by Britain's Royal Philharmonic Society (RPS) on Tuesday. It was the second major award for Gerhaher, who last month was named top male vocalist at the International Opera Awards. Nelsons is the outgoing head of the Birmingham Symphony Orchestra. The RPS, which was founded in 1813 and commissioned Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, gives awards at its annual May dinner …

  • Five paintings missing since World War II returned to Germany

    Five paintings missing since World War II are being returned to Germany from the United States so that they can be given back to their rightful owners, the State Department and Monuments Men Foundation said on Tuesday. "The paintings ... represent an important part of Germany's cultural heritage. They have a long history," Victoria Nuland, Assistant Secretary of State for European affairs, told reporters. "Both sets disappeared at the end of the war and resurfaced in the United States." …

  • Food critic and meat 'evangelist' Josh Ozersky dies in Chicago

    By Fiona Ortiz CHICAGO (Reuters) - Josh Ozersky, an award-winning food critic who preached the wonders of eating meat and founded the Meatopia outdoor food festival, has died in Chicago at age 47. Ozersky was found dead on Monday in a room in Chicago's Conrad Hotel, the Cook County Medical Examiner said on Tuesday. He was in town for the James Beard Foundation Awards for restaurants and chefs, the foundation said. "Josh Ozersky was a meat man. …

  • Las Vegas battery case against singer Chris Brown dropped

    (Reuters) - A misdemeanour battery case against R&B singer Chris Brown has been dropped after the man who accused the performer of punching him during a game of basketball in Las Vegas decided against pressing charges, police said on Tuesday. Brown was subsequently given the option of signing a misdemeanour battery citation or having the case submitted to the Clark County District Attorney's Office for possible prosecution. …

  • 'Satisfaction' guaranteed - Stones' bassist Wyman sells cars
    'Satisfaction' guaranteed - Stones' bassist Wyman sells cars

    A Mercedes-Benz sedan and a Citroen with a Maserati engine that Rolling Stones bass player Bill Wyman says he used to drive to recording sessions and to visit artists and writers in France, will be auctioned off in June, Bonham's said on Tuesday. The cars, a 1966 Mercedes-Benz 250 S and a 1971 Citroen Maserati SM, are to be sold at a car auction in Chichester, England on June 26, the auction house said. It said the Mercedes was valued at 20,000-25,000 pounds($30,400-38,000) while the Citroen …

  • Costumes and replicas, fans fete "Star Wars" as new release nears
    Costumes and replicas, fans fete "Star Wars" as new release nears

    From building Lego spaceships to dressing up as Jedi Knights, fans around the world have celebrated Star Wars Day ahead of the release of the much-anticipated next instalment of the galactic space fantasy franchise. In Australia, "Star Wars" enthusiasts built a five-metre wide replica of Han Solo's Millennium Falcon ship, made from around 250,000 Lego bricks. American Lego master builders, father and son Dan and Chris Steininger, flew in especially for the occasion to lead the construction …

  • Austrian baker causes stir with "tasteless" 9/11 cake

    A Vienna baker has stirred up anger by making a cake depicting Austria's main political parties as New York's twin towers coming under attack from opposition party aircraft. "It's ironic that a baker has no taste," wrote one critic on the website of the mass-circulation Heute tabloid that highlighted the unusual creation. …